There is not much ambiguity when it comes to the “top” finance journals; here is the almost unarguable A-list:
Journal of Finance
Journal of Financial Economics
Review of Financial Studies
Journal of Business
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis
However, assigning a ranking to all of the journals out there is no easy task. Luckily we have several researchers answer this question for us. To name a couple:
Edwin D. Maberly and Raylene M. Pierce, “Citation Patterns Within the Leading Top-Tier Finance Journals: Implications for Journal Rankings and Other Issues“.
Carl R. Chen and Ying Huang, “Author Affiliation Index, Finance Journal Ranking, and the Pattern of Authorship“, Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 13, pp. 1008-1026, 2007.
Thomas Reuters’ Journal Citation Report, which is accessible through many schools’ library subscription to the Social Science Citation Index, is also a good resource.
So, why care about ranking? There is one reason you can’t ignore: “…depending on professorial rank, the present value of the first top finance journal article is between $19,493 and $33,754…”
Steve Swidler and Elizabeth Goldreyer, “The Value of a Finance Journal Publication”, Journal of Finance, Vol. 53, Issue 1, pages 351-363, 1998.
Hmm, $19,493 to $33,754 from 12 years ago. Excellence really pays off.